OLTP vs OLAP – Difference Between Them
Key Difference between OLTP and OLAP
- Online Analytical Processing (OLAP) is a category of software tools that analyze data stored in a database, whereas Online transaction processing (OLTP) supports transaction-oriented applications in a 3-tier architecture.
- OLAP creates a single platform for all types of business analysis needs which includes planning, budgeting, forecasting, and analysis, while OLTP is useful for administering day-to-day transactions of an organization.
- OLAP is characterized by a large volume of data, while OLTP is characterized by large numbers of short online transactions.
- In OLAP, a data warehouse is created uniquely so that it can integrate different data sources for building a consolidated database, whereas OLTP uses traditional DBMS.
What is OLAP?
Online Analytical Processing, a category of software tools which provide analysis of data for business decisions. OLAP systems allow users to analyze database information from multiple database systems at one time.
The primary objective is data analysis and not data processing.
What is OLTP?
Online transaction processing shortly known as OLTP supports transaction-oriented applications in a 3-tier architecture. OLTP administers day to day transaction of an organization.
The primary objective is data processing and not data analysis
Example of OLAP
Any Datawarehouse system is an OLAP system. Uses of OLAP are as follows
- A company might compare their mobile phone sales in September with sales in October, then compare those results with another location which may be stored in a sperate database.
- Amazon analyzes purchases by its customers to come up with a personalized homepage with products which likely interest to their customer.
Example of OLTP system
An example of OLTP system is ATM center. Assume that a couple has a joint account with a bank. One day both simultaneously reach different ATM centers at precisely the same time and want to withdraw total amount present in their bank account.
However, the person that completes authentication process first will be able to get money. In this case, OLTP system makes sure that withdrawn amount will be never more than the amount present in the bank. The key to note here is that OLTP systems are optimized for transactional superiority instead data analysis.
Other examples of OLTP applications are:
- Online banking
- Online airline ticket booking
- Sending a text message
- Order entry
- Add a book to shopping cart
Difference between OLTP and OLAP
Below is the difference between OLAP and OLTP in Data Warehouse:
|Process||It is an online transactional system. It manages database modification.||OLAP is an online analysis and data retrieving process.|
|Characteristic||It is characterized by large numbers of short online transactions.||It is characterized by a large volume of data.|
|Functionality||OLTP is an online database modifying system.||OLAP is an online database query management system.|
|Method||OLTP uses traditional DBMS.||OLAP uses the data warehouse.|
|Query||Insert, Update, and Delete information from the database.||Mostly select operations|
|Table||Tables in OLTP database are normalized.||Tables in OLAP database are not normalized.|
|Source||OLTP and its transactions are the sources of data.||Different OLTP databases become the source of data for OLAP.|
|Data Integrity||OLTP database must maintain data integrity constraint.||OLAP database does not get frequently modified. Hence, data integrity is not an issue.|
|Response time||It’s response time is in millisecond.||Response time in seconds to minutes.|
|Data quality||The data in the OLTP database is always detailed and organized.||The data in OLAP process might not be organized.|
|Usefulness||It helps to control and run fundamental business tasks.||It helps with planning, problem-solving, and decision support.|
|Operation||Allow read/write operations.||Only read and rarely write.|
|Audience||It is a market orientated process.||It is a customer orientated process.|
|Query Type||Queries in this process are standardized and simple.||Complex queries involving aggregations.|
|Back-up||Complete backup of the data combined with incremental backups.||OLAP only need a backup from time to time. Backup is not important compared to OLTP|
|Design||DB design is application oriented. Example: Database design changes with industry like Retail, Airline, Banking, etc.||DB design is subject oriented. Example: Database design changes with subjects like sales, marketing, purchasing, etc.|
|User type||It is used by Data critical users like clerk, DBA & Data Base professionals.||Used by Data knowledge users like workers, managers, and CEO.|
|Purpose||Designed for real time business operations.||Designed for analysis of business measures by category and attributes.|
|Performance metric||Transaction throughput is the performance metric||Query throughput is the performance metric.|
|Number of users||This kind of Database users allows thousands of users.||This kind of Database allows only hundreds of users.|
|Productivity||It helps to Increase user’s self-service and productivity||Help to Increase productivity of the business analysts.|
|Challenge||Data Warehouses historically have been a development project which may prove costly to build.||An OLAP cube is not an open SQL server data warehouse. Therefore, technical knowledge and experience is essential to manage the OLAP server.|
|Process||It provides fast result for daily used data.||It ensures that response to the query is quicker consistently.|
|Characteristic||It is easy to create and maintain.||It lets the user create a view with the help of a spreadsheet.|
|Style||OLTP is designed to have fast response time, low data redundancy and is normalized.||A data warehouse is created uniquely so that it can integrate different data sources for building a consolidated database|
Benefits of using OLAP services
- OLAP creates a single platform for all types of business analytical needs which includes planning, budgeting, forecasting, and analysis.
- The main benefit of OLAP is the consistency of information and calculations.
- Easily apply security restrictions on users and objects to comply with regulations and protect sensitive data.
Benefits of OLTP method
- It administers daily transactions of an organization.
- OLTP widens the customer base of an organization by simplifying individual processes.
Drawbacks of OLAP service
- Implementation and maintenance are dependent on IT professional because the traditional OLAP tools require a complicated modeling procedure.
- OLAP tools need cooperation between people of various departments to be effective which might always be not possible.
Drawbacks of OLTP method
- If OLTP system faces hardware failures, then online transactions get severely affected.
- OLTP systems allow multiple users to access and change the same data at the same time which many times created unprecedented situation.